top of page

The Way Community

Do We Really Have Free Will?

“If God already knows everything I’m going to do, then do I really have a choice? Doesn’t His knowledge mean my future is already set in stone?”

“If God is all-knowing, then He already knows every decision I’ll ever make. But if that’s true, are my choices even real? Am I just acting out a script that God wrote? How can I be free and responsible if my future is already known before I live it?”

God’s foreknowledge isn’t a script — He knows your choices because you’ll freely make them.

This question has been asked for centuries. The tension is real: how can God’s perfect knowledge of the future fit with our real ability to choose?

  • God’s Omniscience:
    The Bible says God knows everything, including the future (Psalm 139:4; Isaiah 46:9–10). He knows every choice you’ll ever make, but knowing is not the same as forcing.

  • God’s Relationship to Time:
    God exists outside of time (2 Peter 3:8). He sees past, present, and future all at once. His knowledge of what will happen isn’t like a human prediction — it’s a timeless awareness of everything. That means His knowing doesn’t cause our choices; it simply reflects them.

  • Freedom to Choose:
    The Bible affirms real human freedom: “I have set before you life and death, blessings and curses. Now choose life” (Deuteronomy 30:19). God’s knowledge of what we’ll choose doesn’t erase the fact that we’re the ones making the choice.

  • Middle Knowledge (Molinism):
    Some theologians describe God’s middle knowledge — His awareness of not just what will happen, but what could happen in every possible circumstance. That means He knows how you would act in any scenario, yet you still freely choose in the actual one.

  • Philosophical Clarity:
    Knowing something will happen doesn’t mean you caused it. If you know your friend always picks chocolate ice cream, that doesn’t mean you forced them to pick it — you just knew them well enough to know what they’d do. God’s foreknowledge works in a similar way: He sees our free choices without taking away our freedom.

  • Biblical Examples:
    Judas betrayed Jesus, and God knew it would happen (John 13:21–27), yet Judas acted from his own will.
    Pharaoh hardened his heart (Exodus 7:3–5). God knew the outcome, but Pharaoh chose it.

  • Theological Implications:
    Moral Responsibility: If we weren’t free, we couldn’t be held accountable. But the Bible clearly holds us responsible for our actions (Romans 14:12).
    Divine Sovereignty: God’s sovereignty and human freedom coexist. His plan unfolds through our genuine choices, showing both His power and His respect for human agency.

Conclusion: God’s knowledge of the future does not cancel human freedom — it confirms it. He knows your choices not because He scripts them, but because from His eternal perspective, He already sees you freely making them.

The REAL Question

If you’re just a machine of chemistry and neurons, then free will is an illusion — and so is love, meaning, or even the idea of right and wrong. But deep down, you live as though your choices matter, because they do. God’s sovereignty doesn’t erase your freedom; it gives it weight. Every “yes” or “no” echoes in eternity.

So the real issue isn’t “Do we really have free will?” — it’s:

  • What are you doing with the freedom you already know you have?

  • Will you keep using it to push God away?

  • Or will you use it to finally surrender to the One who gave you freedom in the first place?

bottom of page